SEO - Topic title inside URL?

[Athlon1600]

I saw some warez sites with this function.

Basically this forums URL with the topic: Real or fake looks like this:
http://www.besthostingforums.com/forum/showthread.php?t=1276

with the topic name inside the URL, the new URL would be:
http://www.besthostingforums.com/forum/showthread.php?t=real_or_fake.html

.. or something like that. This is a good idea for SEO, but how would you do it?

Athlon1600 Reviewed by Athlon1600 on 11th Jun 2008. SEO - Topic title inside URL? I saw some warez sites with this function. Basically this forums URL with the topic: Real or fake looks like this: http://www.besthostingforums.com/forum/showthread.php?t=1276 with the topic name inside the URL, the new URL would be: http://www.besthostingforums.com/forum/showthread.php?t=real_or_fake.html .. or something like that. This is a good idea for SEO, but how would you do it? Rating: 5

[Agrias]

basicly it's no good voor seo, they all do it. But had discussion with jente lately and it seems that google indexes all pages as quick. rather the topic title is in the url or not.
trust me, the biggest forum around hasn't, (warez-bb) , look up warez in google, and first result are them.

[Athlon1600]

yeah I know. They don't even have any keywords tag in their page. probably many sites link to warez-bb so that's why they are so high in google rank

I don't care about how fast google indexes my page. Im interested in higher ranking position.
Topic title in URL must increase your google rank. It wouldn't be logical that this:

showtopic.php?id=4213

ranks better than:

showtopic.php?download_sony_vegas_8

even though they both have the same content

[UltimA]

It won't affect how many pages are indexed, but rather make them more relevant to what it contains.

[Athlon1600]

yup

more relevant = higher rank in google

btw I found a code on how to do this:

http://www.seochat.com/seo-tools/url-rewriting

[Whoo]

basicly it's no good voor seo, they all do it. But had discussion with jente lately and it seems that google indexes all pages as quick. rather the topic title is in the url or not.
trust me, the biggest forum around hasn't, (warez-bb) , look up warez in google, and first result are them.

warez-bb wouldn't have any use for this. They got less than 2k indexed links in google and they don't allow any section to be viewed by guests, meaning google can't crawl any topics => no use for using those URLs.

And yes it's better for SEO trust me. I use it on iGotPorn.org and a topic url looks like this:

http://igotporn.org/forum/asses-of-face-destruction-4-xvid-pornolation-t3809.html

Better relevance in url with the title = better SEO-optimized page = higher ranking plus users will also be more likely to click a static link than just a showtopic.php?id=818181 (example).

[Athlon1600]

yup.
I was just making sure if google really crawls those pages with titles in it since that page is not "real". It's not on a server so I thought how will google see it


thank you for your replies